Hebrews, Amy Peeler. Commentaries for Christian Formation. (Eerdmans: Grand Rapids, 2024) 482pp
This is a refreshing and reassuring commentary. By which I mean, Amy Peeler has written a scholarly commentary that combines careful exegesis with theological reflection, both aimed at encouraging the reader to engage deeply with a text originally intended to warn and reassure. The Preface is both Peeler’s personal testimony of Hebrews as a decisive formative text in the story of her Christian life, and an account of her writing and rewriting of the commentary to achieve its purpose as an exposition for Christian formation.
The Introduction starts with the theology of Hebrews, including Christology, Israel’s Scriptures, and the relation of the text to Jewish faith. In the background, Peeler recognises the tension between Hebrews as a sustained argument for the superiority and finality of Christ over previous forms of divine speech, and sensitivity to Hebrews being read as unqualified super-cession of Jewish faith and tradition. Her closing comment demonstrates exactly why this commentary is so helpful in nuance, sensitivity and faithfulness to the text:
“In sum, this author would never let go of God’s promises to the people of Israel, nor would he compromise on the sole sufficiency of the offering of Jesus Christ. To read this text well today in a post Holocaust world demands humble and honest conversation between Jewish and Christian interpreters of this text, which must take place in communities of mutual respect and deference before the sovereignty and wisdom of God that all desire to serve faithfully.” (11)
Peeler then discusses early hesitations about Hebrews’ place in the canon, its setting and authorship (“written by a member of the broad Pauline network of Gospel ministers”), genre (a hortatory sermon), audience (a community of Christ followers under social and cultural pressure and wondering if confessing Christ is worth the cost). Date, possibly pre 70 CE, since there is no hint of the fall of Jerusalem in the document.
Six pages explain Hebrews as a seminal text for Christian formation, aligning the commentary with the series aims. Two distinctive themes are considered important in establishing the writer’s purpose: a concern to reassure about continuing and gracious access to God through Christ, and taking heed of the warning passages which make clear this is a text to be obeyed by faithful perseverance in a faith which has to be practiced in the long run, looking to Jesus.
The commentary itself is clear, engaged with the text and alert to the goals of Hebrews, which are to stabilise and strengthen a community through theological argument and pastoral encouragement. The focus is Christological, and this is traced through the history and experience of the people of God from the beginning, through exodus, wilderness wanderings, covenant commitments and prophetic warning, example and exhortation, until God’s final spoken acts revealed through and in his Son. Along the way the writer of Hebrews (and the commentator) consider the exaltation and humiliation of Christ, the ascension and high priesthood of Jesus the Son, the warnings about apostasy and the dangers of decisions that may be irrevocable, the call to perseverance, and much else.
Peeler’s comments on Hebrews 6.1-8 are a model of clarity, written in a tone of theological convictions held with humility. Those using this commentary for preaching will be helped by her wise reticence about jumping to pre-judged theological conclusions about this controversial text:
“Teachers of this portion of the letter must exercise great care. The impact of the warning must not be dulled. To turn away from Christ is to turn from God’s blessing to God’s judgement. This is a space in which one would not want to live and would certainly not want to die or meet Christ at his return…On the other hand the text itself allows for the one who has turned away to return to the work Christ has already done…this reading resonates with the patience of God in the parable of the fruitless fig tree in Luke 13.6-9. Multiple chances are given, and time is given before the final end.” (169)
Time and again Peeler shows how well she has read this sermon, how long and persistently she has thought about it. This makes it an unusually engaging commentary in which exegetical skill, theological humility, pastoral awareness and good writing, help the reader get a handle on a text brimming with formative possibilities and bristling with theological argument. There are subject, name and Scripture indices, a select bibliography, and in keeping with the aim and format of the series, fewer footnotes than in the more traditional approach and sometimes footnote overload in academic exegetical commentary.
The volume is a joy to read, and an education in how exegesis and theological commentary of the biblical text can aid Christian formation and Christian preaching. The conclusion is in the form of 10 questions followed by succinct discussion, and acts both as a summary of what has been learned, and a stimulus towards the so what of prayer, praxis and perseverance. Question 9 is a cracker! “How does Hebrews demonstrate the productive discomfort of liminality?”
However many other commentaries a preacher has available, Amy Peeler’s volume must have a place on any shelf, however crowded. Much more so if what is being sought is a treatment of Hebrews in which exegesis, while being an end in itself, then becomes a means of Christian formation towards being more persuaded, determined, and faithful followers of Jesus, “the author and finisher of our faith.” In my estimate, this is commentary writing of the highest order, and on a New Testament document that requires and deserves an expositor who has both studied and lived within the disciplines and promises of its text, and therefore who is well informed about, and formed by, the text of this enigmatic New Testament sermon.
Recent Comments